Back to Blog
AEO7 min read

Why Does Perplexity Say My Pricing Is Confusing? What Happened When Our Own Prices Didn't Match

When our own prices didn't match across pages, Perplexity flagged confusion. What we fixed, and how to keep your facts consistent everywhere.

Griffin Schwartz

VP of Operations at HUNTR

Mixed prices plus a confused AI equals lost trust.

Short answer: AI tools like Perplexity and ChatGPT describe your business using whatever your website and listings say. When those sources disagree on prices, locations or numbers, the AI can't tell which one is true, so it flags confusion or hedges. The fix isn't bigger numbers. It's real numbers, stated the same way everywhere.

Definition you can quote: Fact consistency means every place your business appears online (your website, FAQ, Google Business Profile, social profiles and directories) gives the same prices, address, hours and numbers, so search engines and AI tools get one clear answer.

What did Perplexity say about us?

It happened to us. Our homepage, pricing page and service pages all listed different prices, and Perplexity said our pricing was confusing. It wasn't wrong to be confused. Our own pages didn't agree.

So we fixed it. We made every page give the same pricing answer, and we added real FAQs that answer pricing questions honestly. After that, ChatGPT and Perplexity started quoting our site correctly.

The lesson: AI tools don't reward the most impressive answer. They reward the clearest, most consistent one.

Why does every detail have to match everywhere?

Because search engines and AI tools check your business against itself. If two sources disagree, both look less trustworthy.

It isn't the first time this happened to us. Google's AI Overview once listed us under the wrong name until our website and listings matched; we covered that in What Does ChatGPT Say About Your Business?

"FAQs, and having everything the same everywhere, are so important. When our office moved from Boca Raton to Deerfield Beach, we updated our FAQs, our footer and everywhere else on the site, and it still took Google and AI platforms several days to show that we're in Deerfield Beach. We also had different locations listed in different directories, and we had to fix every one. When your details don't match, search engines trying to understand your company get confused, and that confusion costs you trust." — Griffin Schwartz, VP of Operations at HUNTR

What should you update first when something changes?

"When something changes, the first thing I update is the website. Then I go down a checklist: social media, directories and every backlink that mentions us, and I fix each one. That's exactly how we handled our own move to Deerfield Beach." — Griffin Schwartz

The order:

  1. Your website: every page, the footer and the FAQ
  2. Your Google Business Profile
  3. Social media profiles and bios
  4. Directories and listings
  5. Backlinks and mentions on other sites that list your details

Then give it time. Even after we fixed everything, it took several days for Google and AI tools to catch up.

Should you round up your numbers to look bigger?

No. This is the one we talk almost every new client out of.

"Everyone wants the site to look impressive, so everyone wants to inflate their numbers. We had a Medicare company whose website we helped build, and their CEO came to me worried that their review count and social media following looked low. For a company their size, they were. But they were real, and real numbers are worth more than pretty ones, because Google and AI tools read facts and proof." — Griffin Schwartz

What if a client pushes back?

"Clients push back on showing their real numbers all the time. I tell them this is what Google really wants to see. Real numbers let Google and AI platforms tell your real story. The more your pages, FAQs and listings back each other up, the more the facts pile up, and those tools can confirm the truth instead of getting confused and trusting you less." — Griffin Schwartz

Google's own guidance backs this up. In its advice on helpful content, Google asks, "Is it self-evident to your visitors who authored your content?" and says of its quality framework, "Of these aspects, trust is most important."

Inflating numbers carries legal risk too. In August 2024, the FTC finalized a rule that bans fake reviews and testimonials, including AI-generated ones. It also bans buying fake indicators of social media influence, like followers or views, when the buyer knew or should have known they were fake and uses them to misrepresent their influence for a commercial purpose. The agency can seek civil penalties against knowing violators.

What if you only have a few reviews?

Show them anyway.

"Everyone worries about their numbers, but some proof is always better than no proof. Look at us: right now we have 8 Google reviews. Do we wish we had way more? Yes. But they're real, anyone can trace them back to Google, and that helps us look better in search. It's also the same hard, honest truth we tell our clients." — Griffin Schwartz

A small real number that matches your Google Business Profile beats a big vague one ("hundreds of happy clients") that nothing backs up.

How do you know if it's working?

Check, on a schedule, and be honest about what you find.

"For us and our clients, we run daily SEO, AEO and GEO checks to see where each site shows up, how it's improving and which questions to go after next. That's how we watched one of our manufacturing clients start appearing in ChatGPT, ranking first for some questions, and showing up in Perplexity for long, industry-specific questions. But not all questions are created equal. It depends on how many potential customers actually ask them. Showing up for three questions almost nobody asks doesn't mean much. We saw that firsthand on our own site. When we started 3 to 4 weeks ago, we weren't showing up for any questions at all. Now we show up for a lot of long, specific questions, and they compound. Each one builds trust, helps the site keep growing, and brings in leads." — Griffin Schwartz

We wrote up what that looked like for the manufacturer in our PMG case study. To run a quick check on your own business, see What Does ChatGPT Say About Your Business?

The Real Numbers Test: 5 checks before you publish a figure

  1. Can you prove it? If a customer asked, could you show where the number came from?
  2. Is it the same everywhere? Your website, Google Business Profile, social bios and directories.
  3. Is it current? Update it when it changes.
  4. Is it specific? "8 Google reviews" beats "lots of happy clients."
  5. Would you say it on a call? If you'd hesitate to say it out loud, don't publish it.

Fact Consistency Checklist

  1. Pricing gives one answer, on every page
  2. Your FAQ matches the rest of your site
  3. Your address and hours match on your site, Google Business Profile, social profiles and directories
  4. Review counts and ratings on your site match Google
  5. Every number on your site comes from your own records
  6. No bought followers, views or reviews
  7. When something changes, you update the site first, then social, directories and backlinks
  8. You check what ChatGPT and Perplexity say about you on a regular schedule
Download the printable checklist (PDF)

What does this cost with HUNTR?

The website build is free, and plans start at $99/month with a 12-month minimum term. SEO and AI search work is part of our higher plans. See pricing, or take the free Digital DNA Test. It scores your site across 8 dimensions, including trust. Local to South Florida? See website design in Deerfield Beach.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central, Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content
  2. FTC, "Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials" (Aug. 14, 2024)
  3. HUNTR, PMG case study
  4. HUNTR, Pricing · FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does Perplexity say my pricing is confusing?

Usually because different pages show different prices. Perplexity flagged our pricing as confusing until we made it consistent and added honest FAQs.

Can ChatGPT get my business details wrong?

Yes, if your sources disagree. Check what it says about you regularly, and fix your website first.

How long does it take AI tools to catch up after a change?

It varies. When we moved our office to Deerfield Beach, it took several days for Google and AI tools to show the new location, even after we updated everything.

Should I round up my numbers so they look bigger?

No. Publish real numbers that match your listings. Inflated or inconsistent figures can confuse search engines and AI tools.

What if I only have a few reviews?

Show them. We have 8 Google reviews, and because they're real and traceable to Google, they help more than a vague claim would.

What should I update first when my address or prices change?

Your website first, then your Google Business Profile, social media, directories and any backlinks that list your details.
AI SearchPerplexityTrust

Ready to Put This Into Action?

Let HUNTR's AI-powered sales and marketing automation help you implement these strategies.

Schedule a Call

More Articles